Daniel Penny Acquitted in Subway Chokehold Case; Neely's Family Expresses Disappointment
Former U.S. Marine Daniel Penny was acquitted today in a closely watched trial over the subway chokehold death of Jordan Neely, a homeless street performer whose killing sparked debates about public safety, mental health, and vigilantism.
The jury delivered a not-guilty verdict on all charges, including second-degree manslaughter and criminally negligent homicide, after several weeks of emotional testimony and deliberations.
The incident occurred in May 2023, when Neely, 30, reportedly acted erratically and shouted at passengers on an F train in Manhattan.
Penny, 24 at the time, restrained Neely in a chokehold for several minutes, leading to his death.
The defense argued that Penny acted to protect himself and other passengers from a perceived threat. Prosecutors, however, contended that Penny's use of force was excessive and unjustified.
Jordan Neely’s family expressed deep disappointment at the verdict. “We are heartbroken,” said his father in a statement, adding that the decision reflects systemic failures in valuing the lives of vulnerable individuals.
Civil rights advocates also voiced frustration, with many arguing that the case highlights the urgent need to address homelessness and mental health in the city.
The trial divided New Yorkers and the nation, with some viewing Penny as a hero who acted to defend others, while others condemned his actions as reckless and indicative of biases against the homeless and mentally ill. Demonstrations were held outside the courthouse throughout the trial, underscoring the polarizing nature of the case.
The New York State Conservative Party issued a statement supporting the verdict, describing it as a validation of self-defense in chaotic situations.
"Daniel Penny’s actions were a response to an unpredictable and dangerous moment," the statement read.
The case has reignited conversations about how society addresses homelessness, mental health crises, and the responsibilities of bystanders. Advocates have called for increased funding for social services and training for dealing with mental health emergencies, emphasizing that prevention is key to avoiding such tragedies.
As the city grapples with the fallout from the verdict, Neely's family announced plans to pursue a civil lawsuit against Penny. They vowed to continue advocating for justice and systemic reform, ensuring that Neely’s death sparks meaningful change.
AN OPEN LETTER TO ERIN THOMPSON (A DEEP THINKER)
There’s a feature that allows you to listen to the article. Click on the link below. When the article comes up, to listen, click on this symbol ⧁, right above the title.
https://medium.com/@howardjeagle/an-open-letter-to-erin-thompson-a-deep-thinker-cda638e0764d