Rochester City Council Approves Landmark Good Cause Eviction Law
ROCHESTER, N.Y. — In a significant step toward bolstering tenants' rights and addressing the city’s housing crisis, the Rochester City Council passed the Good Cause Eviction Law last night with a 7-2 vote. The measure aims to protect more than 100,000 renters from unjust evictions and predatory rent increases, solidifying Rochester as the largest upstate New York city to adopt such protections.
The legislation, which prevents evictions of tenants adhering to their lease agreements, requires landlords to demonstrate "good cause" for evictions, such as non-payment of rent or lease violations. It also limits rent increases to a percentage tied to the Consumer Price Index plus 5% or 10%, whichever is lower.
“This victory underscores the power of persistence in addressing the needs of the people,” said Councilmember Kim Smith, reflecting on the years-long advocacy by tenants and housing justice organizations.
The law closes a previously controversial “LLC loophole” by reducing exemptions for small landlords, thereby extending protections to nearly all rental units in the city. This amendment aligns Rochester's law with similar legislation adopted in other New York municipalities, including Albany and Ithaca.
Council President Miguel Meléndez called the legislation a necessary step in addressing the housing inequities faced by the city's 64% renter population. “This is particularly important in communities within our city who have often been marginalized,” he said, emphasizing the law's potential to stabilize neighborhoods and provide renters with long-term housing security.
Councilmembers LaShay Harris and Michael Patterson voted against the measure, criticizing it as being a step towards socialism and for having the potential to push eviction cases into the courts.
The passage follows years of grassroots organizing by tenants and advocacy groups like the City-Wide Tenant Union of Rochester. These groups played a pivotal role in rallying support through public hearings, education campaigns, and advocacy efforts.
“Over a hundred thousand tenants can now rest easy knowing their landlord can’t kick them out just because he wants more money,” said Lisle Coleman, an organizer with the tenant union.
Councilmember Stanley Martin praised the legislation as a testament to the power of co-governance strategies that center the voices of directly impacted communities. “The Good Cause Law prioritizes keeping people in their homes,” Martin said. “It is a crucial step in recognizing that at the center of community health and wellness is safe, secure housing.”
But the passage has elicited varied reactions from landlord groups and property owners. Many landlords express concerns that the legislation could complicate the eviction process and potentially lead to unintended consequences in the rental market.
A significant apprehension among landlords is that the law might effectively create "leases for life," making it challenging to remove tenants even when legitimate issues arise. They argue that the removal of holdover evictions could impede their ability to conduct necessary renovations or address disruptive tenant behavior. Additionally, there is worry that the evidentiary standards required to prove "good cause" for eviction are stringent, potentially leading to increased legal disputes and court involvement.
Additionally, some property owners fear that the legislation may disincentivize investment in the local housing market. They argue that increased regulations could lead landlords to withdraw units from the market or adopt more stringent tenant selection criteria, thereby reducing the availability of affordable housing.
Despite these concerns, proponents of the law emphasize its role in protecting tenants from unjust evictions and unreasonable rent hikes, aiming to enhance housing stability within the community.
The law will take effect after being signed by Mayor Malik Evans, who has yet to issue a formal statement on the legislation. In conjunction with the law’s implementation, the council approved additional measures to ensure its success, including:
Establishing a task force to oversee enforcement and monitor outcomes.
Developing a public education campaign to inform tenants of their rights.
Partnering with external organizations to evaluate the law’s long-term effectiveness.
Councilmember Mary Lupien expressed optimism while stressing the need for continued action to address Rochester’s broader housing challenges. “Good Cause Eviction is a critical tool in our fight against housing instability, but it is only the beginning,” she said.
Rochester’s renters, who have long endured high rates of rent burden and evictions, now have a safeguard against some of the most destabilizing aspects of the housing market.
“For today, we celebrate a hard-won victory for our city,” Martin added. “Tomorrow, we regroup, reorganize, and push for further progress.”
This story will be updated as more details become available.
When do we vote for the City Counsel?